Hi everyone!! Looking for a great place to get a meal? Somewhere with good service, tasty food and an inviting atmosphere? Finding a place to eat that has all those qualities can be difficult if you’re not from the area or unsure where to pick. I know when I travel, eating out can make or break your trip. So I thought it would be nice to give some of my suggestions of favorite restaurants in Sheboygan and help recommend a place you may enjoy!! Since I’ve lived in Sheboygan my whole life, I thought it would be great to write, Best Restaurants in Sheboygan Wisconsin. I’ve also included a few restaurants that are a little bit outside Sheboygan that I felt were worth mentioning.
This article was updated on August 27, 2022.
*Note: This post contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.
BEST RESTAURANTS IN OR NEAR SHEBOYGAN WISCONSIN
SOUTH PIER PARLOR
434 S Pier Dr., Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-395-2675
If your looking for a cool treat, this is definitely the place to go. Great atmosphere and delicious ice cream. My husband and I always get the fudge when we go here.
The South Pier Parlor is only open during certain seasons so check their hours to make sure they are open.
THE GREEK CORNER
1402 S 8th Street, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-287-7264
Over 30 years of cooking across the Atlantic on the Mediterranean in Athens, Greece, family has carried us to the lakeside town of Sheboygan, WI. The Greek Corner is a restaurant that I added to this article. Scott and I decided to check this place out and were blown away by the delicious tasting food. If you like Greek food, stop in and see for yourself.
LOCAL PRESS EATERY
502 S 8th Street, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-287-7338
My friend suggested we meet at the Local Press Eatery for lunch one afternoon and I was really impressed with my meal. It has been added to my favorite places to eat in Sheboygan. Stop in for one of their signature hamburgers and Blue Moon shakes.
ANGLERS
518 S Pier Dr., Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-395-2406
The first time I went to Anglers, it became my new favorite restaurant. My favorite thing to order is the Bok Choy Salad. After eating it, I found a recipe so I could make it at home. The food is so good here and there is also eating outside. The location of this restaurant is by other shops and the South Pier Parlor.
BOMALLIES
2427 Calumet Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920 395-2868
BoMallies is a restaurant, caterer and food truck. They have an eclectic menu with interesting fresh flavors. Their dining room is intimate and cozy and there is outdoor seating, when weather permits! My daughter Paige highly recommended BoMallies. We were so happy with the food, atmosphere and service that I added it to my favorite places to eat in Sheboygan. They are open Wednesday – Saturday for dinner and will open in the Fall for brunch. When you get close to arriving here, pay close attention. It is really easy to pass by.
UMI SUSHI AND STEAK HOUSE
519 N 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920- 783-8108
I was very hesitant on eating at Umi Sushi because I have never eaten sushi and don’t have a desire to start. Paige loved it so much she told me I had to go and get something on the menu that wasn’t sushi. We’ve been in there a few times now and I wanted to add it to my favorite restaurants in Sheboygan. Love the atmosphere, the service is outstanding and the food was delicious. If you are like me and don’t want to eat sushi, there is a Hibachi meal you can get.
GREECE E SPOON
1217 N. 8th St., Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-287-3591
Another great tasting restaurant in Sheboygan that has been added to the favorite list. My favorite meal that I order when I go in is the Chicken pesto sandwich and the lemon lavender malt. If you are near the 8th Street area and looking for a great place to dine in, check out Greece E Spoon. They are only open certain hours so make sure to call before you drive to confirm they are open.
EL CAMINO
823 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-208-6851
Delicious food and great atmosphere. My favorite meal to order from here is the taco salad and the chocolate fried ice cream. It looks like their hours have changed so make sure to check their Facebook page to see when they are open.
PARKER JOHN’S
705 Riverfront Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-453-0299
Parker John’s is high on my list of favorite restaurants in Sheboygan.
The building is very inviting and the food was delicious.
There is outside eating with great views of the riverfront.
This is a unique place to check out with great food and friendly staff.
ARROSTO
1418 N 13th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 783-6012
We had heard from an acquaintance the food at Arrosto was delicious and the portions were outrageous. I ordered the smaller of the two sizes and couldn’t finish my sandwich, there was so much food.
This restaurant does not have dining in (unless they have added since we’ve been there.) Scott and I took our lunch and went to the board walk to eat at a picnic table and enjoy the weather and lake views. This is a great place to get good food and wonderful service. Definitely one of my new favorites in Sheboygan!!
WEATHER CENTER
809 Riverfront Dr., Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-459-9283
This is a great place to get a great cup of coffee or a delicious smoothie and sit by the water and relax!!
The Weather Center is on the board walk, so if you feel like taking a walk, this is a great place to visit!!
RUPPS DOWNTOWN
925 N. 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-459-8155
This is a great place to dine at for a romantic night out or with a group of people. The atmosphere is cozy and the food is delicious. This restaurant is located down town, so it’s close by other shops as well.
HORSE AND PLOW
419 Highland Drive, Kohler, WI 53044
Phone: 457-8000
Another great place to eat at is the Horse and Plow in Kohler, WI. It is a bit of a drive from Sheboygan but worth mentioning. The parking can be tricky so get your directions ready before you head out. (We always park underground. If the GPS takes you to an underground parking lot it is working.)
Shannon and I made this place our yearly Christmas exchange choice for where we opened gifts and had dinner for Christmas every year. The food is great and the atmosphere is cozy.
MAJERLE’S BLACK RIVER GRILL
5033 Evergreen Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-803-5115
This place is always hopping, so there might be a wait. It is worth it though. The food is priced reasonable and so delicious. Good place to visit for a great meal and fun night out. This restaurant is a bit of a drive from downtown Sheboygan so make sure to check the days and hours of service so you don’t make the drive and they are not open.
LUIGI’S
2910 Kohler Memorial Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-452-1100
Another great place to get a pizza!! My favorite here is the tiramisu dessert. I haven’t found anywhere else that is comparable. There are many different meal options here!! Great food and nice staff.
HARRYS DINER
2504 Calumet Dr., Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: 920-458-5200
4024 WI-42, Sheboygan, WI 53083
Phone: 920-459-4530
There are two restaurants located in Sheboygan for Harrys Diner. Both are open for breakfast and lunch. Each time I have been to Harrys Diner, the food has been outstanding. If you are looking for a nice place for breakfast or lunch, Harry’s Diner is a good spot to pick.
OFF THE RAIL
44 Gottfried St, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020
Phone: 920-876-4194
Off the Rail is a cute little coffee shop located in Elkhart Lake, but worth the drive. This is where I met my husband for the first time and it is also where he proposed to me.
We picked this place for a meet up spot and enjoyed a coffee outside. Great atmosphere and also great service.
Visit our travel page to see other articles with more fun things to do.